Mighty Mo

Last night I invented a new pleasure, and as I was giving it the first trial an angel and a devil came rushing toward my house. They met at my door and fought with each other over my newly created pleasure; the one crying, "It is a sin!" -- the other, "It is a virtue!" - The New Pleasure- Gibran Khalil Gibran

Thursday, January 05, 2006

NO!!! I am not a Maharashtrian!




Every time I introduce myself, I find that I need to clarify that I am not a Maharashtrian. I am Chitrapur Saraswat Brahmin from Mangalore. It is about time that I have more to say about my community than just that. So here goes. It may sound like a history lesson, that’s because it is!

The Saraswat Brahmins claim descent from a Brahmin caste mentioned in ancient Hindu scriptures as inhabiting the Saraswati River valley, the geographic location of which is unknown. The actual origins of this community and the circumstances of its relocation to the areas that they now inhabit are shrouded in mystery.

My ancestors are Aryans, like every other Indian’s

One of the theories lays claim to the fact that my ancestors migrated to all parts of India from the valleys of Kashmir. Most historians suspect that after a few thousand years of flowing, the Saraswati began to dry out and became non-existent by 1000 BC. The entire region started becoming arid and with no means of growing their crops, the Saraswats had no choice but to move. This period of history saw many civilizations abandoning their settlements. This migration was spread over centuries. The last of the exodus is believed to be in 350 BC due to a wide spread famine which lasted for 12 years.

The Saraswat Brahmins residing on the western coast of India (primarily in Maharashtra, Goa, and Karnataka) are thought to have descended from these Kashmiri Brahmins. Substantial evidence has been set forth by several historians relating that the Kashmiri Brahmins migrated to Goa by the eleventh century AD.

The Exodus from Goa

Goa was chosen mainly for its fertile soil and sea ports with flourishing overseas trade. Another reason for their migration into Konkan is the marital relationships between the Kadamba king Jayakeshi (1050-1080 AD) of Goa and the Saraswat king from Trihotra. Some historians believe that the king of Trihut sent ninety-six families from ten gothras to the new land to propagate religion and philosophy at the request of the Kadamba King.

The Saraswats enjoyed peace and prosperity in Goa for 400 years. Goa was attacked by Muslim rulers destroying many temples and forcing the Hindus into converting to Islam. To avoid religious persecution several Saraswat families moved to Kanara. This explains why most of the family deities are in Goa ( Mangeshi & Shantadurga). Ours though is at Ankola in North Kanara. The picture above is of that very same temple.
To think that if this exodus hadn't happened I would be Goan! But then, if none of the migrations had happened I would probably be European!

Why my surname is unpronounceable!

The group who migrated to Karnataka was dominated by educators and administrators. This migrant group moved inland to North and South Kanara. Their intelligence and experience as administrators, allowed some of them to secure prominent positions as accountants in the courts of the Hindu rulers of the time. One such Hindu king of the Keladi kingdom was so impressed by the diligence and skills of his Saraswat accountant that he decreed that every village in his kingdom, be administered by a Saraswat. Eventually these Saraswats took on the name of the village as their last name. At last I know why my surname is the tongue twister that it is.

Finally why we are Chitrapur Saraswat Brahmins

Although the Saraswats were well respected as accountants, they were not readily recognized as true Brahmins by the local Brahmins, because they had no spiritual guru, which was the norm then. I think it was plain jealousy. Anyway it became essential to seek a spiritual preceptor for the community. They pleaded with a Saraswat Sanyasi, Parijananasharma Swamy, visiting from North India, to become their Guru. He consented to guide the community and established a new Mutt for them in Gokarn in 1708 AD. In 1739 AD, the ruler Basavappa Nayaka II donated land in Gokarn to build a mutt in reverence to their primary deity, Shri Bhavanishankar.

His successor Shankarasharma Swamy travelled to Chitrapur and attained Samadhi there in 1757 AD. Another Mutt was established in Chitrapur near Shirali in North Kanara and it became the headquarters of the Mutt. Over time the connection with other groups in Goa was lost and the belief that we are the descendents of Kashmiri Brahmins became stronger. And eventually the sub-sect -Chitrapur Saraswat Brahmins (also referred to as Bhanaps) was formed and continued following the Smarta (followers of Lord Shiva) tradition while the Gaud Saraswat Brahmins in Goa and Karnataka drifted to the Vaishnava (followers of Lord Vishnu) faith.

During the British rule, the Bhanaps took to English education earlier than others. Subsequently, they were able to obtain key jobs at the district offices and the Collector’s offices in Mangalore, Honavar and Karwar. They were also quickly employed as administrators in the Cotton and Textile export industry in Kumta, Hubli and Dharwad. Many Bhanaps made their way into the cosmopolitan city of Bombay by the late 1800's.

One aspect that I haven’t touched upon is that our community speaks Konkani, a language that is considered as one of the Indo-Aryan languages descending from the Middle Indic Prakrits. The script too seems to be lost in the hoary past otherwise why the need for English, I would be writing in Konkani!

17 Comments:

Blogger Vasu the terrible said...

Hey stumbled onto your blog, from I dont know where. But pretty interesting..

1) I guess like me, many people confuse you for Rohini hattangady.. the only other famous person with whom you share a interesting last name.. maybe that is what is the source of confusion. Everyone thinks, rohini is a maharashtrian and maybe all hattangadis are therefore maharashtrian... Nevertheless it was pretty interesting to read your blog.

2) YOU are a FERGIII!!! coool.. cos, I studied next door at IMDR and I had a lot of friends in fergi... I dont know when you cleared but my friend's brother was a student there.. gaurav raye.. he is in the airforce now.. ya.. I know fergi is a huge place and that was the way I dreamt a college would be huge and lots of trees. I enjoyed the hostel though...

Tue Feb 07, 11:31:00 PM PST  
Blogger Vasu the terrible said...

you are from IMDR !!!??? vow.. ?? I passed out in 98... bhupi, kandy and GI...

I think kandy is the only one left as of now...

small world...

vasu

12:41 AM

Sat Feb 18, 12:42:00 AM PST  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow, I never knew this! thanks! I was looking for this info and guess what, your page came up!! You are famous (on google:))

Thu Apr 20, 11:49:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

hmm this one post did for me, what kanara saraswat's monthly mag couldn't do for me all this while. lol..

Fri May 19, 05:44:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Really great article..!!

Wed Oct 18, 01:49:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Great post man. I, for one, am sick and tired of people calling me Maharshtrian, and then asking if my native place is Mangalore...

I'm proud of my Aryan roots. Saraswat Pride \m/ \m/ Great post, Keep them coming.

Amogh Gulwady.

Wed Oct 18, 03:25:00 AM PDT  
Blogger MM said...

Nice post! :)
Also it was great to see the Shree Lakshminarayan- Mahamaya Devasthanam photo on ur blog... aamgali kuldevataa. Bless U!
Keep writing Mohita!

Wed Oct 18, 08:21:00 PM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Nice post! Keep it going!
-- Sandeep Hattangady

Wed Oct 18, 10:53:00 PM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

nice!!!I am a teacher of history for more than 15 years teaching about Cholas, hoysalas and the like but knew next to nothing about our wonderful past. keep up the good work!!!!


Anuradha Benegal

Thu Oct 19, 11:26:00 PM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Mohita !!!

Great pleasure to catch you after such a long time. My god .. good experience to go through those history pages. You have really provided a good peice of details.

Ajay Prasad
Batch 2000

Mon Nov 06, 10:25:00 PM PST  
Blogger dhaval said...

Dear Mohita,
I am a Bhanap like you, but dont feel a sense of revulsion like some others do when people call me a Maharashtrian.
Infact, i am proud to be called one, having adopted Marathi food, culture and language along with my Konkani roots.
The linkages between Marathi and Konkani run deep. Indeed, the first evidence of the Marathi script in Devnagari was found in an inscription at Shravan Belgova in Karnataka and bears a strong resemblance to Konkani.
The Marathi in Saint Dnyaneshwar's 'Dnyaneshwari' bears a strong resemblance to Konkani and hence, it will be right to deduce that the two languages are interlinked. Infact, Konkani may be called an ancient dialect of Marathi.
Many Saraswats have distinguished themselves in Maharashtra. Some names include P.L Deshpande, Barister Nath Pai, S.K Patil, Jaywant Dalvi, Nikhil Wagle etc.
The Saraswat community has also produced some of the best writers in Marathi.
Hence, while we stress on our Saraswat roots, let us not forget our Marathi and Maharashtrian linkages!

Sat May 19, 08:26:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Hi Mohita,

You may say what's in a surname or family name. But it would have avoided the confusion if your ancestors had retained their Saraswat family name instead of leaving it out and adopting the name of the village they settled in Mangalore region, leaving you crying out loud!!!!

Hattangadi is a village somewhere in the region of south of Goa and north of Kerala on the west coast of India.

And 'angadi' is a sure Kannada word that denotes 'shop', there are other names that end with 'angadi' in MANGALORE REGION are 'Uppinangadi' (salt shop), HaLeyangadi(old shop), Belthangadi, Mudarangadi, Guddyangadi etc.

The name hattangadi is combination of two words, 'hatthu Angadi'

In Kannada, Hatthu means a. number ten or climb.

Eithere were ten shops or the shop was on a hilly place or built on an elevated platform and had steps to climb to reach it. Fascinating, analogy? probably.

By replacing surname with village name, that too the village your ancestors settled in Mangalore region after fleeing Goa,could be confusing, and causes identity crisis!!.

What I have observed is the Pai family that fled Goa and settled in Tonse (a few km north of Udupi). They called themselves Tonse Pai family. So by retaining 'Pai' we know for sure they are Saraswat Konkani Brahmans who fled Goa and we mostly know where the Saraswats originated from (or their actual origin).

So now you know of the man who started the Syndicate Bank, T.A. PAI (Tonse Ananta Pai).

Similarly, kingfisher beer guy, Vijay Mallya is a Saraswat Konkani from Mangalore.

The Tonse Pai family is connected to Manipal. Manipal Academy of Education, Manipal Power Press, Manipal Hospital etc..all Pai affiliates.

Whereas if he had mentioned his name Ananta Tonse..what can we make out??

Probably your parents will be able to advise you your family name and that can be legally added. Then probably you will be called Hattangadi A. Prabhu? Sounds impressive, right??

Even many Catholics of Mangalore, whose ancestors fled Goa after conversion have retained their Saraswat family names such as Prabhu, Pai, Kamath, Nayak and so on and do speak chaste Konkani.

Just adding my two bits.

MD.

Tue Sep 28, 01:38:00 PM PDT  
Blogger Mo said...

WOW...I haven't visited my blog in ages and didnt realise that so many people had left comments. My apologies for not responding before this. Wish I could write more often, but let me first get some sleep! Corporate life...sigh!

@Oliver
Can you please let me know how you will be using the info?

@MD
Thanks for your comments. You are referring to Gowd saraswat brahmins while I am refrring to chitrapur sarawat brahmins- vaishnavites vs shaivites being the basic difference plus the slight difference in the dialect. So CSBs use only the village names and we don't have surnames.

@anonymous
plese notice I say every OTHER, not every. hope that clarifies.

Wed Oct 27, 12:52:00 AM PDT  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Awesome!!! this is indeed an interesting article... Mi name's Siddheshwar Rajadhyax even at times I feel the need to explain myself of being a Konkani. I don't like being called a Maharashtrian but cant go on explaining to everyone cause some idiots just dont understand!!! This is common even in our Konkani community since I am from Bombay those Konkani's who reside from Karnataka when informed about my roots they just don't understand, mainly cause we(our family) don't really talk to each other in Konkani(unless its a family get together or we are in Goa) that often mostly it's Hindi or English and Marathi at times due to the surrounding influence.

PROUD TO BE A KONKANI!!!

Thu Dec 02, 10:39:00 PM PST  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I find Bhanaps weird in many ways. Though progressive and liberal in approach, Bhanaps have been known to exhibit idiosyncratic traits not quite common among other Brahminical communities. Their culinary habits are very peculiar with huge variety of complicated dishes involving coconuts and rice (e.g. Alni Kheer). All in all, I hold Bhanaps in high regard for retaining their individuality and culture but am curious to understand the all pervasive weirdness.

Thu Nov 13, 10:24:00 AM PST  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Wow! I was delighted to read your blog. It is about time we proudly introduce ourselves as Chitrapur Saraswat Brahmins and not just as Konkanis. Growing up in Mumbai, people associated Konkanis with Goan Catholics and were not aware that Konkanis were hindus/ brahmins etc.
We have a rich heritage which goes way back into the BC era. Our community has provided our country and far beyond regions with some of the world's brightest, talented and most accomplished individuals; Shyam Benegal, Leena Chandavarkar, Girish Karnad, Rohini Hattangadi, Nandan Nilekani, Prakash Padukone, Anuradha Paudwal, Deepika Padukone to name only a few.
We have the most dynamic and strong spiritual leader ( Our present Mathadhipati H.H. Parama Pujya Shrimat Sadyojat Shankarashram Swamiji) leading our community, inspiring devotion and an eagerness in every section of the samaja to strengthen the connection with ones spiritual inheritance-the Guru, Math and God.
I am Proud to be a Chitrapur Saraswat brahmin!

Wed Dec 10, 09:01:00 PM PST  
Blogger Meera Sundararajan said...

Hi
I stumbled upon your blog by chance.. !!! It was wonderful reading about your roots. I heard about the "Chitrapur Saraswat Brahmins" for the first time from a Mangalorean friend who enlightened me about the difference. She told me about Nandan Nilekeni, Suman Kalyanpur and ofcourse the Pais...!!! Many people naturally assume that places like Goa are largely Catholic ( thanks to Bollywood and the tourism industry I guess) . But a large part of Goa is Hindu and it has two famous temples! I have a close Catholic friend from Mangalore. Their family still holds on to their Hindu name( I think they were Kamaths). Most people unfortunately don't get it...!! They used to ask her silly stuff like "Why does your mom wear a sari, black beads and bindi?" I wish there would be more people like you writing about their roots that would help others learn more about our culture and people.

Mon Oct 19, 01:28:00 AM PDT  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home